Understanding the Difference: Have as a State vs Have as an Action
📖 Reading time: 8 minutes | Level: A2-B2
Why This Matters
The verb 'have' is one of the most common words in English, but it works in two completely different ways. When you say 'I have a car,' you're describing a state – something you own. But when you say 'I'm having lunch,' you're describing an action happening right now. This difference matters because stative 'have' usually can't be used in continuous tenses, while action 'have' regularly appears in continuous forms. Mixing these up leads to sentences like 'I'm having a sister' or 'I have dinner right now' – errors that sound very unnatural to native speakers and can confuse your listener about whether you're talking about a permanent situation or a temporary activity.
⚠️ Common Mistakes:
Using continuous tenses with stative 'have': *I'm having a car, *She's having blue eyes
Using simple tenses with action 'have' when describing ongoing activities: *I have lunch now instead of I'm having lunch now
Not recognizing that the noun after 'have' determines whether it's a state or action: 'have a house' (state) vs 'have a party' (action)
🎯 By the end of this lesson, you'll be able to confidently choose between simple and continuous forms of 'have' based on whether you're describing a permanent state or a temporary action.
Practice: Choose the Correct Form
Read each sentence carefully and select the most appropriate form of 'have' to complete it. Pay attention to whether the sentence describes a state (possession, characteristic, relationship) or an action (activity, experience, event).
Question 1casual/phone conversation
I can't come to the phone right now because I _____ a shower.
💡 Explanation: Use 'am having' because taking a shower is a temporary action happening right now. Action 'have' can be used in continuous tenses. 'Have' (simple present) would be wrong because it suggests a habitual action, not something happening at this moment.
Question 2everyday conversation
She _____ three children and a large dog.
💡 Explanation: Use 'has' (simple present) because this describes a permanent state – her family situation. Stative 'have' for relationships cannot be used in continuous tenses, so 'is having' is incorrect. While 'has got' is possible in British English, 'has' is the standard neutral form.
Question 3business/scheduling
We _____ a meeting at 3pm, so I'll be busy then.
💡 Explanation: Use 'are having' because this describes a scheduled action/event happening at a specific future time. The continuous form with future meaning is natural for planned activities. 'Have' alone doesn't convey the future timing clearly, and 'will have' is less natural for already-scheduled events.
Question 4casual conversation
Do you _____ a car? I need a ride to the airport.
💡 Explanation: Use 'have' (simple present) in questions about possession/ownership. This is a state, not an action. 'Are having' is incorrect because stative 'have' doesn't use continuous forms. 'Have got' is possible in British English but less common in questions.
Question 5storytelling/narrative
They _____ dinner when the power went out.
💡 Explanation: Use 'were having' (past continuous) because eating dinner is an action that was in progress when something else happened. Action 'have' works in continuous tenses. 'Had' (simple past) would suggest the dinner was finished before the power outage.
Question 6everyday conversation
My brother _____ blue eyes like our father.
💡 Explanation: Use 'has' because eye color is a permanent physical characteristic – a state, not an action. 'Is having' is completely wrong because you cannot use continuous tenses with characteristics. 'Has got' is possible in British English but 'has' is more standard.
Question 7casual/home situation
Don't disturb John – he _____ a nap upstairs.
💡 Explanation: Use 'is having' because taking a nap is a temporary action happening right now. Action 'have' can be used in continuous tenses to show something is in progress. 'Has' would be wrong because it doesn't show the action is happening at this moment.
Question 8professional/business
I _____ a lot of experience in marketing, so I can help you.
💡 Explanation: Use 'have' because experience is a state – something you possess over time, not a temporary action. Stative 'have' cannot be used in continuous forms, so 'am having' is wrong. 'Have had' suggests a completed past action rather than current possession.
Question 9everyday routine
We usually _____ breakfast at 7am on weekdays.
💡 Explanation: Use 'have' (simple present) for habitual actions and routines. Even though eating is an action, we use simple present for regular habits. 'Are having' would only be correct for something happening right now, not a general routine.
Question 10everyday conversation
She _____ a beautiful voice – she should be a singer.
💡 Explanation: Use 'has' because having a beautiful voice is a permanent characteristic or quality – a state. 'Is having' is incorrect because you cannot use continuous tenses with characteristics. 'Has got' is possible in British English but less standard.
Question 11phone conversation
I can't talk long because I _____ lunch right now.
💡 Explanation: Use 'am having' because eating lunch is a temporary action happening at this moment. The phrase 'right now' signals continuous aspect. 'Have' alone doesn't convey that the action is in progress at this moment.
Question 12everyday conversation
They _____ a house in the countryside where they spend weekends.
💡 Explanation: Use 'have' because owning a house is a state – possession. Stative 'have' for possession cannot be used in continuous forms, so 'are having' is wrong. 'Have got' is possible in British English but 'have' is more universal.
Question 13casual/social
Are you _____ a good time at the party?
💡 Explanation: Use 'having' because 'have a good time' is an experience/action happening now. This is one of the most common action uses of 'have' and regularly appears in continuous forms. 'Have' would be wrong for asking about the current experience.
Question 14everyday conversation
He _____ no patience for people who are always late.
💡 Explanation: Use 'has' because patience (or lack of it) is a personal quality or characteristic – a state. 'Is having' is incorrect because you cannot use continuous tenses with personal qualities. 'Has got' is possible but less standard.
Question 15business/formal
The company _____ financial difficulties at the moment.
💡 Explanation: Use 'is having' because experiencing difficulties is a temporary situation happening now. 'Have difficulties' can be used as action 'have' (experiencing problems), especially with time markers like 'at the moment.' 'Has' would suggest a more permanent state.
Question 16everyday conversation
I _____ two sisters and one brother in my family.
💡 Explanation: Use 'have' because family relationships are permanent states. Stative 'have' for relationships cannot be used in continuous forms, so 'am having' is completely wrong. 'Have got' is possible in British English but 'have' is more standard.
📝 Connected Practice Passages
Passage 1
Sarah couldn’t answer her phone because she a job interview at that moment. She a lot of experience in sales, which made her a strong candidate. After the interview, she planned to lunch with her friend who a restaurant downtown.
Gap 17: Use 'was having' because a job interview is a temporary action that was in progress at a specific time in the past. Action 'have' works in continuous tenses. 'Had' would suggest the interview was finished.
Gap 18: Use 'has' because experience is something you possess – a state, not an action. Stative 'have' cannot be used in continuous forms. 'Had' would incorrectly suggest she no longer has this experience.
Gap 19: Use 'have' (infinitive after 'to') because eating lunch is an action/activity. After 'planned to,' we need the base form. 'Be having' is not used after 'to,' and 'has' is the wrong form.
Gap 20: Use 'owns' because possessing a restaurant is a state. While 'has' would be grammatically possible, 'owns' is clearer and more precise for business ownership. 'Is having' is completely wrong for possession.
🔑 Key Learning: Notice how 'have' switches between action (interview, lunch) and state (experience, ownership) depending on what follows it and the context.
Passage 2
Tom a terrible day yesterday. He breakfast when he spilled coffee on his shirt. He no clean clothes left, so he had to wear something wrinkled. Later, while he a meeting with his boss, his phone kept ringing.
Gap 21: Use 'had' (simple past) because we're describing the overall nature of the day as a completed past event. 'Was having' would only work if we were describing a moment in progress. 'Has had' is present perfect, wrong for 'yesterday.'
Gap 22: Use 'was having' because eating breakfast is an action that was in progress when something else happened (he spilled coffee). Past continuous shows the ongoing action. 'Had' would suggest breakfast was finished.
Gap 23: Use 'had' because having clothes (or not having them) is a state of possession. Stative 'have' cannot be used in continuous forms. 'Has' is wrong because the story is in past tense.
Gap 24: Use 'was having' because a meeting is an action/event that was in progress when his phone rang. Action 'have' works in continuous tenses to show ongoing activities. 'Had' would suggest the meeting was finished.
🔑 Key Learning: In past narratives, use continuous forms (was having) for actions in progress and simple past (had) for states or completed events.
Passage 3
A: Do you any plans for tonight? B: Yes, I dinner with my parents. They’re visiting from out of town. A: That’s nice. How long they ___[gap3b]___ in the city? B: Just two days. They a hotel room near the station.
Gap 25: Use 'have' in questions about possession of plans. Even though plans relate to future actions, asking about having plans uses stative 'have.' 'Are having' would be wrong here. 'Had' is past tense.
Gap 26: Use 'am having' because eating dinner is an action/activity with future meaning (tonight). Action 'have' with continuous form can express future scheduled activities. 'Have' alone doesn't clearly show the future timing.
Gap 27: Use 'are' because 'How long are they in the city?' asks about duration of stay. This isn't about 'having' anything – it's about being somewhere. 'Have' doesn't fit this question structure.
Gap 28: Use 'have' because having a hotel room (booking/renting it) is treated as a state of possession during their stay. 'Are having' would be wrong for this type of possession. 'Had' is past tense, but they currently have the room.
🔑 Key Learning: In conversations, distinguish between having plans (state), having dinner (action), and other uses of 'have' based on context.
Passage 4
Many students difficulty understanding when to use continuous tenses with ‘have.’ The problem is that ‘have’ two different meanings. When you a possession or characteristic, use simple tenses. But when you an activity or experience, continuous tenses are fine.
Gap 29: Use 'have' because 'have difficulty' in general statements about ongoing problems uses simple present. Even though experiencing difficulty is somewhat action-like, in general statements we use simple present. 'Are having' would only work for a specific current situation.
Gap 30: Use 'has' because possessing meanings/definitions is a state. The verb 'have' itself has (possesses) two meanings – this is stative. 'Is having' would be wrong for this type of possession.
Gap 31: Use 'have' in general rules and explanations. When describing how the language works in general (not a specific moment), use simple present. 'Are having' would only work for a specific current situation.
Gap 32: Use 'are having' because this clause describes the action/experience scenario where continuous tenses are appropriate. The sentence is explaining when continuous forms work, so it demonstrates that usage. 'Have' would be less clear in showing the continuous aspect.
🔑 Key Learning: Even in explanations about grammar, the same rules apply: use simple forms for general truths and states, continuous forms for specific ongoing actions.
📚 Deep Dives
Deep Dive: Have as a State
Core meaning: Expresses possession, ownership, relationships, characteristics, or qualities that exist as ongoing states rather than temporary actions or events
📖 Grammar
As a verb:
Patterns: have + noun (possession): have a car, have money, have + noun (relationship): have a sister, have friends, have + noun (characteristic): have blue eyes, have patience, have got + noun (British): have got a problem
• “She has three cats and a dog”• “I have two brothers”• “He has brown hair and green eyes”• “They have a beautiful house by the lake”
⚡ Important: Stative 'have' generally CANNOT be used in continuous tenses. Don't say: *I'm having a car, *She's having blue eyes, *They're having a house
🔗 Common Collocations
have a house/car/phonehave children/siblings/parentshave blue/brown/green eyeshave time/money/patiencehave experience/knowledge/skillshave a problem/question
Register: Neutral – used in all contexts from casual conversation to formal writing
💡 Tip: If it's something you OWN, something you ARE RELATED TO, or a QUALITY you possess permanently, use simple tenses: have/has/had
⚠️ Confusion Alert: Don't confuse with action 'have'. If you can replace 'have' with 'own' or 'possess,' it's stative and cannot be continuous.
Deep Dive: Have as an Action
Core meaning: Expresses participation in activities, experiences, events, or consumption that occur at specific times and involve dynamic actions rather than permanent states
📖 Grammar
As a verb:
Patterns: have + noun (activity): have breakfast, have a shower, have + a/an + noun (event): have a meeting, have a party, be having + noun (continuous): I'm having lunch, She's having fun, have + a + noun (experience): have a good time, have trouble
• “We're having dinner at 7pm”• “She had a shower this morning”• “They're having a party tomorrow night”• “Are you having a good time?”
⚡ Important: Action 'have' CAN be used in continuous tenses because it describes activities happening at specific times, not permanent states
🔗 Common Collocations
have breakfast/lunch/dinnerhave a shower/bathhave a meeting/party/conversationhave a look/thinkhave fun/trouble/difficultyhave a good/bad timehave surgery/treatment
Register: Neutral – extremely common in everyday conversation and informal writing
💡 Tip: If it's something you DO or EXPERIENCE at a specific time (not something you own), you can use continuous tenses: am having/was having
⚠️ Confusion Alert: Can often be replaced with more specific verbs: have breakfast = eat breakfast, have a shower = take a shower, have a meeting = hold/attend a meeting
🎯 Using Them Together
The key to using 'have' correctly is understanding that the NOUN following 'have' determines whether it's a state or an action. The same verb form 'have' works completely differently depending on what comes after it.
Decision Flowchart
❓ Does it describe possession, ownership, or having something?
✅ If yes: Use HAVE AS A STATE (simple tenses only)
↓ If no: Continue
❓ Does it describe a relationship or family connection?
✅ If yes: Use HAVE AS A STATE (simple tenses only)
↓ If no: Continue
❓ Does it describe a physical characteristic or personal quality?
✅ If yes: Use HAVE AS A STATE (simple tenses only)
↓ If no: Continue
❓ Does it describe eating, drinking, or consuming?
✅ If yes: Use HAVE AS AN ACTION (can use continuous)
↓ If no: Continue
❓ Does it describe an activity, event, or experience happening at a specific time?
✅ If yes: Use HAVE AS AN ACTION (can use continuous)
↓ If no: Use simple 'have'
Example Using All Terms:
Sarah HAS a beautiful apartment downtown (state – possession). She HAS two roommates (state – relationship) who both HAVE brown hair (state – characteristic). Right now, they'RE HAVING breakfast together (action – eating) because they'RE HAVING a house meeting (action – event) at 9am to discuss bills. Sarah usually HAS patience (state – quality) for these discussions, but today she'S HAVING trouble (action – experiencing) concentrating because she HAS a headache (state – condition).
Why Each Term Works:
HAS a beautiful apartment: state/possession – cannot say 'is having'
HAS two roommates: state/relationship – cannot say 'is having'
HAVE brown hair: state/characteristic – cannot say 'are having'
RE HAVING breakfast: action/eating – continuous is correct
RE HAVING a house meeting: action/event – continuous is correct
HAS patience: state/quality – cannot say 'is having' (usually)
S HAVING trouble: action/experiencing – continuous is correct here
HAS a headache: state/condition – cannot say 'is having'
Quick Reference Card
have as a state
Possession, relationships, characteristics – permanent states
✓ have a car/house, have a sister, have blue eyes – NEVER continuous
✗ Don't use continuous tenses (*I'm having a car is WRONG)
✓ having breakfast/lunch, having a meeting, having fun – CAN be continuous
✗ Don't use for possession or permanent characteristics
💡 Final Tip: Quick test: Can you replace 'have' with 'own' or 'possess'? → STATE (no continuous). Can you replace it with a more specific action verb like 'eat,' 'hold,' or 'experience'? → ACTION (continuous OK). The noun after 'have' is your biggest clue!
← Previous
Page 1 of 1
Next (Coming Soon) →
Manage your privacy
We use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. We do this to improve browsing experience and to show (non-) personalized ads. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional
Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.